Follow me on Twitter. @RobShmerling
Sometimes it looks like people attempting to make healthy food decisions and watching their weight gain can't appear to catch a break.
Past studies have linked consumption of sugar-sweetened beverages to heart disease, hypertension and obesity. So it's easy to know the appeal of weight loss plan soft drinks and other artificially sweetened beverages. If you drink two cans of Coke a day, switching to weight loss plan soda can cut your calorie intake by as much as 8,400 calories monthly. Unless you add recent sources of calories, this will result in some serious weight reduction over time.
but now, a study have raised the likelihood that artificial sweeteners in weight loss plan drinks may increase the chance of dementia and stroke.
Can weight loss plan drinks really be bad to your brain?
Researchers analyzed health data from nearly 3,000 adults who filled out dietary surveys, and determined their incidence of stroke or dementia over 10 years. The results were alarming.
Compared to individuals who said they didn't eat weight loss plan drinks, those that had at the very least one per day were thrice more more likely to have a stroke, and thrice more more likely to develop dementia. Regular (non-diet) soft drink consumption was not related to an increased risk of mental problems. And the outcomes didn't change when accounting for other necessary aspects equivalent to gender, weight loss plan, smoking and physical activity.
Of course, there's more to the story.
Before you get discouraged or quit in your favorite weight loss plan endlessly, take into account that these kinds of studies have some major limitations that may result in false conclusions. For example:
- It is unattainable to account for each single factor affecting the outcomes. For example, individuals with diabetes or a family history of diabetes may select sugar-free soft drinks more often than people without diabetes. So it can have been their diabetes and family history, not their dietary intake of sentimental drinks, that was accountable for their high rates of stroke and dementia.
- This form of study cannot establish cause and effect. Even if individuals who drank more weight loss plan soft drinks had higher rates of mental illness, we will't ensure that weight loss plan soft drinks were the cause.
- This study didn't consider the general health effects of weight loss plan soft drinks. It's possible that they're still a healthier alternative than sugar-sweetened beverages.
- The study was conducted when most artificially sweetened beverages contained saccharin (Sweet'N Low, Sweet Twin), acesulfame-K (Sunett, Sweet One) or aspartame (NutraSweet, Equal). New sweeteners, equivalent to sucralose (as in Splenda), were unlikely to be added.
- Although those that consumed weight loss plan soft drinks had the next risk of stroke or dementia, only 3 percent of the study population had a stroke and about 5 percent had dementia. Therefore, while the next risk was observed amongst weight loss plan beverage drinkers, the general risk was relatively low amongst these individuals.
- The study only checked out artificially sweetened soft drinks. He didn't have a look at the usage of artificial sweeteners in foods or beverages aside from soft drinks.
To understand how concerned we ought to be and How Whether artificial sweeteners could cause these health problems (or others) would require additional research.
In the meantime…
I even have to confess, this study has made me rethink my habits. Would it's higher if I start adding sugar to my coffee as a substitute of my current routine of adding sucralose? I'm not convinced and this study doesn't give me any guidance.
But for those who drink numerous weight loss plan soft drinks, this study should provide you with pause — possibly carefully. Or possibly drinking plain water wouldn't be such a nasty idea.